Dear respected Sufi Vai,
I also agree with you.Let we hope and act for the best of Bangalee and Bangladesh!
Dear Anu,I am also BUET Graduate of 1977 and is working in Multi Million Dollars Energy, Water infrastructure development projects in Many countries including Bangladesh for 36 years. Many of the WB. ADB aided projects I have successfully implemented in BangladeshI endorse your views that Bangladesh Army does not posses technical capability to design and implement such a major road bridge which will require state of the art precise engineering skills and excellent construction skills. Bangladesh Army can assist implementation process and act as watchdog to resist local mastani, chadabajeey and harassment of project consultants and Construction contractors. But they can not construct such a engineering intensive mega structure,.BestEngr Khondkar A SalequeOn Sun, Feb 3, 2013 at 4:35 PM, Engr. Shafiq Bhuiyan <firstname.lastname@example.org> wrote:
Being a civil engineer (graduated from BUET with 1st class in 1980 and worked in both Government and Private organization in Bangladesh, Oman and New Zealand) I polite disagree with this concept. I might be wrong. But I am giving my idea.
I ponder Engineering Core of Bangladesh Army cannot be the "main contractor" or able to carry out such a highly
· Multi-disciplinary and
· Gigantic work of high risk
Engineering Core of Bangladesh Army does not have similar or nearly similar work experience (wrt Size, capacity, complexity and technicality). It is not like Hateerjhil or a small Road Flyover project!
They do not have required
· Manpower and
· Logistic support
To carry out such a very technical, highly sophisticated, Multi-disciplinary, extremely complicated and gigantic work with high risk.
But they can get some real work experience - if they do some works as sub-contractor of main contractor, which can be used in next similar but smaller size project!
What Engineering Core of Bangladesh Army can do and contribute as a:
Major or main sub-contractor of the main international contractor for some civil, mechanical or electrical works, like,
· Piling works,
· Construction of Precast RCC girders,
· Pre-stressing of Girders
· Road and pavement works
Beximco Engineering Ltd was main subcontractor to M/S Hyundai Ltd of South Korea (main contractor of the Bangabandhu Jamuna Bridge).
Engineering Core of Bangladesh Army can also be main "transport subcontractor" of all materials related to the Padma bridge project and approach roads and other road & pavement works, river training works etc.
They can contribute most in this item and local CHADABAZI, MASTANI could be avoided.
They can also work jointly in Project Management of this project and get experience to carry out such a multi-disciplinary work.
Army Engineering Core may be main maintenance contractor / agent after completion of the bridge
But they cannot be the main contractor of this huge multidiscipline project like Padma Bridge.Any positive and constructive criticism, different opinion and suggestions are welcome.
"Sustha thakon, nirapade thakon ebong valo thakon"
Shuvechhante,Engr. Shafiqur Rahman AnuAuckland,New Zealand