Banner Advertise

Wednesday, June 24, 2009

[chottala.com] Re: [khabor.com] Lesson from Plassey - Zia vs Zafar [MBI Munshi revisited]



 
 
Dear Mr. MBI Munshi
 
I belive you now. I am sure you did not write the article in NFB.
As a matter of fact, I felt little awkward when I first saw your
name in the byeline ..... I thought, people change, so it took it
on a good faith ....
In any case, there are quite a few points to ponder in
the article.....truth is always stranger than fiction ....
but that is beside the point especially when I am talking to you ...
Thanks for your patience ....
 
Best regards
 
Syed Aslam

 



 
On 6/24/09, MBI Munshi <mbimunshi@gmail.com> wrote:
Dear Mr. Syed Aslam,

It really doesn't matter with me whther my credibility with the BNP remains intact or not. The point is I did not write the article and so this is a form of fraud by the person who had originally circulated the article and those who know that I did not write seeing my previous rejections.

Regards

MBI Munshi

On Thu, Jun 25, 2009 at 1:43 AM, Syed Aslam <syed.aslam3@gmail.com> wrote:
Dear Mr. MBI Munshi

Plausible denial ..... I hope, your credibility with BNP remain
intact ......    !
 
Thanks
 
Regards
 
Syed Aslam
[Note: Sender Syed Aslam, neither endorses nor contradicts the views expressed by our erudite blogger Barrister MBI Munshi. It is up to the readers to       comment.


 
On Wed, Jun 24, 2009 at 11:27 AM, MBI Munshi <mbimunshi@gmail.com> wrote:

Dear Mr. Aslam,


That is a fake and fabricated write-up. I never wrote such an article. This is the third time in 4 years that this article has appeared in my name. It has been circulated by RAW to discredit me and the BNP. I disown it and its contents and reject any association with it.

 Regards

 

MBI Munshi

On Wed, Jun 24, 2009 at 10:44 AM, Syed Aslam <syed.aslam3@gmail.com> wrote:
 
Lesson from Plassey - Zia vs Zafar
[Barrister MBI Munshi's writeup  revisited]
 
Zia vs Zafar

Monday October 24 2005 23:08:53 PM BDT
 
MBI Munshi, Bangladesh
First published in "News rom Bangladesh":
http://www.bangladesh-web.com/view.php?hidRecord=67716

 
Nabab Siraj was not an excellent ruler; East India Company and their collaborators publicized him as an eccentric autocrat. He could not save his grandfather's kingdom from the British merchants. He was too lenient to the merchants and too naïve about their intention. Ultimately, his naiveté and lenience paid off. He lost his kingdom and life; Bangla lost its independence. After 100 years of bad publicity by British and their local collaborators he cam back in the pages of history as a symbol of our independence; a symbol of our lost pride.

 
Modern propaganda ministers and pet historians also publicized Sheikh Mujib as a bad ruler too. People thought everything would be solved automatically after the independence, denying the fact that nation building is a long term tedious job. No nation has been developed until several decades of independence. Modern day Robert Clive, Jagat Shetth, Rajballav, etc. were working behind the scene.

Eventually Mujib was pushed to establish a totalitarian system BAKSHAL; even though he said, "if my people don't like it, I will revert" in a speech. General Zia wrote an article in Daily Bichitra supporting BAKSHAL. Despite being a lenient ruler he will be in the pages of history as he led the nation to independence. His vigorous stance for Bangalee rights amidst Paki generals' red eyes will keep in the pages of history as a super hero.

The independence lost through Siraj's defeat in 1757 was gained back by Mujib's rigid struggle for "six-point demands," win in 1970 election, unbending negotiation tactics with Paki dictators and finally the Liberation War.

Siraj's death led to a dark era of colonial rule. Mujib's death prompted a U-turn from the spirit of liberation and eventually brought the War Criminals and religion traders to power. From a plural secular nation the U-turn took us back to a backward nation that is longing for 7th century style theocracy; that is intolerant to minorities (Hindus, Kadianis, etc.). Now the country is heading for a Taleban style revolution.

The British merchants and their local collaborators like Jagat Shetth, Raj Ballabh gong and their successors, denigrated Siraj for a century after 1757. Mustaq-Zia- Ershad-Golam gong blacked out Mujib from Bangladesh for a long time after 1975. Siraj's killer Miran, backed by British and Mir Zafar, never faced justice for killing the Nabab. Mujib's killers, backed and rewarded by Mustaq- Zia- Ershad-Khaleeda gong escaped justice too.

There are several analogies between Mir Zafar Ali Khan and General Ziaur Rahman.

1. Mir Zafar acquired the Army Chief position by his good service to Murshid Kuli Khan. General Zia acquired Army Chief of Staff position by good job, as a sector commander, announcer of independence in liberation war, and afterwards serving Sheikh Mujibs government. Even appraising BAKSAL.

2. Mir Zafar was personally a religious and honest man and was popular at his time. But, he let the British and Hindu merchants virtually loot the country. Ziaur Rahman was a financially honest man and popular, but was dishonest in every other respect. All his ministers were corrupt and some patronized dacoits like Imdu, Galkata Kamal; they virtually looted the country.

3. Mir Zafar was the chief of Siraj's army. General Zia was a senior general at Mujib's time and Chief of Staff at the time of 1975 carnage.

4. Mir Zafar remained inactive when Jagat Shetth, Raj Ballabh, and British merchants defeated Nabab. Ziaur Rahman remained inactive when Faruk-Rashid-Mushtaq gong killed Mujib, his family, and the leaders of liberation war. [killer Farooq's clime, Bangladesh a Legacy of Blood. Zia's response was "don't come to me if you fail" (what a subidhabadi!)].

5. Mir Zafar awarded the Jagat Shetth, Raj Ballabh, and British merchants afterwards, when he came to power. General Zia awarded Farooq and Rashid Bangladesh Embassies in different countries after he came to power. He rewarded the razakars and gong for their loyalty to Paki colonialists and war criminals.

6. Mir Zafar kept silent when Miran killed Siraj. General Zia kept silent when his officers (later he made them ambassadors) killed Sheikh Mujib and leaders in the Jail.

7. Mir Zafar let Miran escape punishment. General Zia let Farooq-Rashid gong escape justice. Zia amended the constitution to save the killers (the black Indemnity Ordinance).

8. Mir Zafar's treason led the death of liberation itself leading to a colonial rule for centuries. Zia's treason led the death of spirits of liberation finally taking War Criminals and traitors to power. The country is now heading towards being a black shadow of Pakistan and Talebans.

9. Siraj was hated by the subsequent regimes like Mir Zafar and British rulers. Mujib is also blacked-out by the subsequent regimes like Zia, Ershad, Khaleda.

10. Mir Zafar demolished "monarchy" and promoted "colonialism", both existing in many underdeveloped countries then. General Zia demolished totalitarian BAKSHAL and promoted "militarism", both existing in many underdeveloped countries at his time. His election fiasco made world records.

11. Mir Zafar promoted treason, letting the Englishmen take power. He was finally hunted down by his own creation- treason. General Zia promoted killing and assassination by adopting "Indemnity Ordinance" in the constitution, freeing the punished war criminals from jails, freeing "seven murder" convict from jail, taking 11 murder convict to Hizbul Bahar, appointing the killers of Mujib in different Embassies, creating musclemen on campus. He was finally hunt down by his own creation – treason and killing. The brutality of his killing reflected his own ruthlessness towards any dissent.

12. Mir Zafar let East Indian Company loot the country. Zia let goons and thugs loot the country. He created hundreds of bank loan defaulters by forcing banks to lend money to his party goons. He took young talents and notorious killers in the same ship "Hizbu Bahar" together and taught them evade taxes. He also freed 2 thousand criminals from jails who were not only collaborators of Paki Junta, but also took part in killing, raping, looting, and torching freedom fighters.

MBI Munshi, Bangladesh
******************************
Sent by: Syed Aslam
[Note: Sender Syed Aslam, neither endorses nor contradicts the views expressed
          by our erudite blogger Barrister MBI Munshi. It is up to the readers to 
          comment. Barrister Munshi is the author of a recently published book
           'The India Doctrine'

 My Photo 

Name: MBI Munshi
Location: Dhaka, Bangladesh
On Wed, Jun 24, 2009 at 9:11 AM, <bd_mailer@yahoo.com> wrote:
Lesson from Plassey

 
23rd June. The 252nd anniversary of Plassey Tragedy. This day is the mourning and pathetic day for patriotic nationalist and Pro-Islamic people. Plassey always encourages the people of our country to forge a solid-rocked national unity and defend the independence, sovereignty and Islamic values of our country. The hearts of the people trembled with fear while hearing the hollowness of Plassey. After the death of Nawab Ali Bardi Khan, his beloved grandson Siraj-ud-dowla ascended the throne and became the last independent Nawab of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa.
 
The young Nawab Siraj-ud-dowlah always tried to defend the independence of Bengal since his ascession to throne. His close relatives and royal servants could not accept him since his ascession. Some plotters injected conspiracy to dethrone him at the Qasim Bazaar Kuthi. Of them Ghasheti Begum, Raja Raj Ballabh, Raydurlabh, Jagatsheth, Raja Krishna Ballabh, Manik Chand, Amir chand, Amir Beg, Khadim Hossein, Yar Latif Khan, Watson and Commander-in-chief Mir Jafar Ali Khan were the plotters. Moreover, some exclusive Hindu government employees and Brahminist Hindu Zam-indars dissatisfied with Nawab Siraj-ud-dowlah and implicated with the plotters to dethone him.
 
At a moment, a hostility was created between Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah and the British East India company focusing to fortify the Fort William in Calcutta.
The East India Company accomplished to fortify the Fort William disparaging the decree of Nawab. Therefore, Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah invaded Calcutta and conquered the Fort William. After that, the East India Company rescued the Fort William and Joined with the Plotters to dethrone Nawab Siraj-ud-|Dowlah. At a moment, a treaty was singed between Mir Jafar and Robert Clive to make Mir Jafar the puppet Nawab of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa.
Once Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah decided to fight with the alien East India Company on the battlefield of Plassey. He caused to take an oath with Mir Jafar and others to fight with the East India Company touching the Holy Quran at any cost. But he could realise that Mir Jafar would betray him. In June 23, 1757 CE, both the Nawab's troops and Clives English troops were gathered near by the Bhagirathi river.
 
There were 57,000 native soldiers of Nawab's forces and there were 3000 English soldiers of Clive's forces. At a moment, a fierce battle was broken out. First, the cannons of Nawab forces were roared. Of 57,000 native forces, the commander-in-chief Mir Jafar, Jagat Sheth and their troops enjoyed the Battle standing on the battle field like puppet. The commander Mohanlal, Mir Mardan and French Commander Sinfrey fought valiantly to stem the British forces. We came to know that Jagat Sheth helped Clive's forces actively and joked with Mir Jafar sitting on an elephant. Once, Mir Jafar advised Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah to cease the battle and Nawab decreed to cease the battle believing Mir Jafar.
 
Before that, the English forces fled to the mango grove in the wake of strong resistance of Nawab's forces. After the ceasefire, the Nawab forces went to the tent. At that time Mir Jafar sent a letter to Robert Clive to raid on the Nawab's forces. Then, the British forces swooped down the Nawab's forces and Nowab's forces were diverted. At that time, Mir Mordan was martyred from the fire of Cannon.
 
Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah was defeated deplorably and helpless Nawab went to Murshidabad. Nawab Siraj-ud-Dollah started his journey to Patna by boat with his wife and daughter aimed at fighting with the British forces again to defend the independence. On the way of his jouney to Patna, he was nabbed by the forces of Mir Qasim at Bhaghwan gola and sent with his wife and daughter to Murshidabad. He was detained at a closet of Zafargonj. The betrayer Mir Jafar became the Puppet Nawab of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa by the help of British forces. Both Clive and Miron, the son of Mir Jafar selected Mohammadi Beg to assassinate Nawab Siraj. Mohammadi Beg assassinated Nawab Sirajud-dowlah in July 2, 1757 CE. Thus, Bangladesh as well as the Sub continent was subjugated by the British rulers for two-hundred years. With the continuous struggle after Plassey, Bangladesh got her aspiring independence through the war of liberation of 1971. So, we can teach lesson from Plassey, if we cannot defend our freedom and sovereignty, we will have to bear another threat like Plassey.
 
Despite achieving independence, the cluches of vultures have fallen on our country yet as well as we are victimised of alien aggression. Here is some references i.e., the US imperialists intend to set up their military camp in our country, the Indian hegemonists are also directing their water aggressions on our rivers such as turning our lands of the country into a desertification with building both Farakka and Tipaimukh Dam. But some new Mir Jafars keep silence. After that both the US imperialists and Indian hegemonists are plotting to sway over Bangladesh for a long time. Some so-called Pro-US and Pro-Indian Civil Society, intellectuals and the donors implicated with the alien conspiracy. Consequently, the state Emergency was imposed by the masterminds of those conspirators and empowered the illegal army-backed caretaker government in January 11, 2007. The illegal army-backed caretaker government was prevailed for two years.
 
The patriotic people came to know that who are the real traitors, betrayers, subservient and puppets of alien forces. They did many anti-state activities against country's interest by imposing illegal power as subservient of both US imperialism and Indian hegemony. As a result of their conspiracies, the alien forces empowered the grand alliance governemnt to implement their interests. The persons now in power and the groups of civil society are New Mir Jafors.
The present government adopted subservient foreign policies like the then 1/11 government to the alien forces such as formation of Anti-terrorist South Asian Task force with USA and India, TIFA treaty with USA, giving corridors to India in the name of Asian High Way and giving opportunity to the US to set up their naval camps on the plea of building deep sea-port in the Bay of Bengal etc. Moreover, the marciless killings at Pilkhana, harrassment of some NSI officers with 10-arm's haul case without any cause despite the implication of Indian insurgents in this case astonished the people. In this way, the independence, sovereignty and Islamic values may be destabilised due to the anti-state activities of the government and New Mir Jaffors in the name of Pro-US and Pro-Indian intellectuals of Civil Society.
 
The government should give up these activities and should give the priority over the country's interest. So we have to realise that the Plassey can reiterate over the country and destabilise our sovereignty, independence and Islamic values. So, it is the duty of all to forge a greater national unity and defend our independence and sovereignty with the lesson from Plassey.
 








__._,_.___


[* Moderator's Note - CHOTTALA is a non-profit, non-religious, non-political and non-discriminatory organization.

* Disclaimer: Any posting to the CHOTTALA are the opinion of the author. Authors of the messages to the CHOTTALA are responsible for the accuracy of their information and the conformance of their material with applicable copyright and other laws. Many people will read your post, and it will be archived for a very long time. The act of posting to the CHOTTALA indicates the subscriber's agreement to accept the adjudications of the moderator]




Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe

__,_._,___

[chottala.com] Re: [khabor.com] Lesson from Plassey - Zia vs Zafar [MBI Munshi revisited]



Dear Mr. MBI Munshi

Plausible denial ..... I hope, your credibility with BNP remain
intact ......    !
 
Thanks
 
Regards
 
Syed Aslam
[Note: Sender Syed Aslam, neither endorses nor contradicts the views expressed by our erudite blogger Barrister MBI Munshi. It is up to the readers to       comment.


 
On Wed, Jun 24, 2009 at 11:27 AM, MBI Munshi <mbimunshi@gmail.com> wrote:

Dear Mr. Aslam,


That is a fake and fabricated write-up. I never wrote such an article. This is the third time in 4 years that this article has appeared in my name. It has been circulated by RAW to discredit me and the BNP. I disown it and its contents and reject any association with it.

 Regards

 

MBI Munshi

On Wed, Jun 24, 2009 at 10:44 AM, Syed Aslam <syed.aslam3@gmail.com> wrote:
Lesson from Plassey - Zia vs Zafar
[Barrister MBI Munshi's writeup  revisited]
 
Zia vs Zafar

Monday October 24 2005 23:08:53 PM BDT
MBI Munshi, Bangladesh
First published in "News rom Bangladesh":
http://www.bangladesh-web.com/view.php?hidRecord=67716

Nabab Siraj was not an excellent ruler; East India Company and their collaborators publicized him as an eccentric autocrat. He could not save his grandfather's kingdom from the British merchants. He was too lenient to the merchants and too naïve about their intention. Ultimately, his naiveté and lenience paid off. He lost his kingdom and life; Bangla lost its independence. After 100 years of bad publicity by British and their local collaborators he cam back in the pages of history as a symbol of our independence; a symbol of our lost pride.

Modern propaganda ministers and pet historians also publicized Sheikh Mujib as a bad ruler too. People thought everything would be solved automatically after the independence, denying the fact that nation building is a long term tedious job. No nation has been developed until several decades of independence. Modern day Robert Clive, Jagat Shetth, Rajballav, etc. were working behind the scene.

Eventually Mujib was pushed to establish a totalitarian system BAKSHAL; even though he said, "if my people don't like it, I will revert" in a speech. General Zia wrote an article in Daily Bichitra supporting BAKSHAL. Despite being a lenient ruler he will be in the pages of history as he led the nation to independence. His vigorous stance for Bangalee rights amidst Paki generals' red eyes will keep in the pages of history as a super hero.

The independence lost through Siraj's defeat in 1757 was gained back by Mujib's rigid struggle for "six-point demands," win in 1970 election, unbending negotiation tactics with Paki dictators and finally the Liberation War.

Siraj's death led to a dark era of colonial rule. Mujib's death prompted a U-turn from the spirit of liberation and eventually brought the War Criminals and religion traders to power. From a plural secular nation the U-turn took us back to a backward nation that is longing for 7th century style theocracy; that is intolerant to minorities (Hindus, Kadianis, etc.). Now the country is heading for a Taleban style revolution.

The British merchants and their local collaborators like Jagat Shetth, Raj Ballabh gong and their successors, denigrated Siraj for a century after 1757. Mustaq-Zia- Ershad-Golam gong blacked out Mujib from Bangladesh for a long time after 1975. Siraj's killer Miran, backed by British and Mir Zafar, never faced justice for killing the Nabab. Mujib's killers, backed and rewarded by Mustaq- Zia- Ershad-Khaleeda gong escaped justice too.

There are several analogies between Mir Zafar Ali Khan and General Ziaur Rahman.

1. Mir Zafar acquired the Army Chief position by his good service to Murshid Kuli Khan. General Zia acquired Army Chief of Staff position by good job, as a sector commander, announcer of independence in liberation war, and afterwards serving Sheikh Mujibs government. Even appraising BAKSAL.

2. Mir Zafar was personally a religious and honest man and was popular at his time. But, he let the British and Hindu merchants virtually loot the country. Ziaur Rahman was a financially honest man and popular, but was dishonest in every other respect. All his ministers were corrupt and some patronized dacoits like Imdu, Galkata Kamal; they virtually looted the country.

3. Mir Zafar was the chief of Siraj's army. General Zia was a senior general at Mujib's time and Chief of Staff at the time of 1975 carnage.

4. Mir Zafar remained inactive when Jagat Shetth, Raj Ballabh, and British merchants defeated Nabab. Ziaur Rahman remained inactive when Faruk-Rashid-Mushtaq gong killed Mujib, his family, and the leaders of liberation war. [killer Farooq's clime, Bangladesh a Legacy of Blood. Zia's response was "don't come to me if you fail" (what a subidhabadi!)].

5. Mir Zafar awarded the Jagat Shetth, Raj Ballabh, and British merchants afterwards, when he came to power. General Zia awarded Farooq and Rashid Bangladesh Embassies in different countries after he came to power. He rewarded the razakars and gong for their loyalty to Paki colonialists and war criminals.

6. Mir Zafar kept silent when Miran killed Siraj. General Zia kept silent when his officers (later he made them ambassadors) killed Sheikh Mujib and leaders in the Jail.

7. Mir Zafar let Miran escape punishment. General Zia let Farooq-Rashid gong escape justice. Zia amended the constitution to save the killers (the black Indemnity Ordinance).

8. Mir Zafar's treason led the death of liberation itself leading to a colonial rule for centuries. Zia's treason led the death of spirits of liberation finally taking War Criminals and traitors to power. The country is now heading towards being a black shadow of Pakistan and Talebans.

9. Siraj was hated by the subsequent regimes like Mir Zafar and British rulers. Mujib is also blacked-out by the subsequent regimes like Zia, Ershad, Khaleda.

10. Mir Zafar demolished "monarchy" and promoted "colonialism", both existing in many underdeveloped countries then. General Zia demolished totalitarian BAKSHAL and promoted "militarism", both existing in many underdeveloped countries at his time. His election fiasco made world records.

11. Mir Zafar promoted treason, letting the Englishmen take power. He was finally hunted down by his own creation- treason. General Zia promoted killing and assassination by adopting "Indemnity Ordinance" in the constitution, freeing the punished war criminals from jails, freeing "seven murder" convict from jail, taking 11 murder convict to Hizbul Bahar, appointing the killers of Mujib in different Embassies, creating musclemen on campus. He was finally hunt down by his own creation – treason and killing. The brutality of his killing reflected his own ruthlessness towards any dissent.

12. Mir Zafar let East Indian Company loot the country. Zia let goons and thugs loot the country. He created hundreds of bank loan defaulters by forcing banks to lend money to his party goons. He took young talents and notorious killers in the same ship "Hizbu Bahar" together and taught them evade taxes. He also freed 2 thousand criminals from jails who were not only collaborators of Paki Junta, but also took part in killing, raping, looting, and torching freedom fighters.

MBI Munshi, Bangladesh
******************************
Sent by: Syed Aslam
[Note: Sender Syed Aslam, neither endorses nor contradicts the views expressed
          by our erudite blogger Barrister MBI Munshi. It is up to the readers to 
          comment. Barrister Munshi is the author of a recently published book
           'The India Doctrine'

 My Photo 

Name: MBI Munshi
Location: Dhaka, Bangladesh
On Wed, Jun 24, 2009 at 9:11 AM, <bd_mailer@yahoo.com> wrote:
Lesson from Plassey

 
23rd June. The 252nd anniversary of Plassey Tragedy. This day is the mourning and pathetic day for patriotic nationalist and Pro-Islamic people. Plassey always encourages the people of our country to forge a solid-rocked national unity and defend the independence, sovereignty and Islamic values of our country. The hearts of the people trembled with fear while hearing the hollowness of Plassey. After the death of Nawab Ali Bardi Khan, his beloved grandson Siraj-ud-dowla ascended the throne and became the last independent Nawab of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa.
 
The young Nawab Siraj-ud-dowlah always tried to defend the independence of Bengal since his ascession to throne. His close relatives and royal servants could not accept him since his ascession. Some plotters injected conspiracy to dethrone him at the Qasim Bazaar Kuthi. Of them Ghasheti Begum, Raja Raj Ballabh, Raydurlabh, Jagatsheth, Raja Krishna Ballabh, Manik Chand, Amir chand, Amir Beg, Khadim Hossein, Yar Latif Khan, Watson and Commander-in-chief Mir Jafar Ali Khan were the plotters. Moreover, some exclusive Hindu government employees and Brahminist Hindu Zam-indars dissatisfied with Nawab Siraj-ud-dowlah and implicated with the plotters to dethone him.
 
At a moment, a hostility was created between Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah and the British East India company focusing to fortify the Fort William in Calcutta.
The East India Company accomplished to fortify the Fort William disparaging the decree of Nawab. Therefore, Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah invaded Calcutta and conquered the Fort William. After that, the East India Company rescued the Fort William and Joined with the Plotters to dethrone Nawab Siraj-ud-|Dowlah. At a moment, a treaty was singed between Mir Jafar and Robert Clive to make Mir Jafar the puppet Nawab of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa.
Once Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah decided to fight with the alien East India Company on the battlefield of Plassey. He caused to take an oath with Mir Jafar and others to fight with the East India Company touching the Holy Quran at any cost. But he could realise that Mir Jafar would betray him. In June 23, 1757 CE, both the Nawab's troops and Clives English troops were gathered near by the Bhagirathi river.
 
There were 57,000 native soldiers of Nawab's forces and there were 3000 English soldiers of Clive's forces. At a moment, a fierce battle was broken out. First, the cannons of Nawab forces were roared. Of 57,000 native forces, the commander-in-chief Mir Jafar, Jagat Sheth and their troops enjoyed the Battle standing on the battle field like puppet. The commander Mohanlal, Mir Mardan and French Commander Sinfrey fought valiantly to stem the British forces. We came to know that Jagat Sheth helped Clive's forces actively and joked with Mir Jafar sitting on an elephant. Once, Mir Jafar advised Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah to cease the battle and Nawab decreed to cease the battle believing Mir Jafar.
 
Before that, the English forces fled to the mango grove in the wake of strong resistance of Nawab's forces. After the ceasefire, the Nawab forces went to the tent. At that time Mir Jafar sent a letter to Robert Clive to raid on the Nawab's forces. Then, the British forces swooped down the Nawab's forces and Nowab's forces were diverted. At that time, Mir Mordan was martyred from the fire of Cannon.
 
Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah was defeated deplorably and helpless Nawab went to Murshidabad. Nawab Siraj-ud-Dollah started his journey to Patna by boat with his wife and daughter aimed at fighting with the British forces again to defend the independence. On the way of his jouney to Patna, he was nabbed by the forces of Mir Qasim at Bhaghwan gola and sent with his wife and daughter to Murshidabad. He was detained at a closet of Zafargonj. The betrayer Mir Jafar became the Puppet Nawab of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa by the help of British forces. Both Clive and Miron, the son of Mir Jafar selected Mohammadi Beg to assassinate Nawab Siraj. Mohammadi Beg assassinated Nawab Sirajud-dowlah in July 2, 1757 CE. Thus, Bangladesh as well as the Sub continent was subjugated by the British rulers for two-hundred years. With the continuous struggle after Plassey, Bangladesh got her aspiring independence through the war of liberation of 1971. So, we can teach lesson from Plassey, if we cannot defend our freedom and sovereignty, we will have to bear another threat like Plassey.
 
Despite achieving independence, the cluches of vultures have fallen on our country yet as well as we are victimised of alien aggression. Here is some references i.e., the US imperialists intend to set up their military camp in our country, the Indian hegemonists are also directing their water aggressions on our rivers such as turning our lands of the country into a desertification with building both Farakka and Tipaimukh Dam. But some new Mir Jafars keep silence. After that both the US imperialists and Indian hegemonists are plotting to sway over Bangladesh for a long time. Some so-called Pro-US and Pro-Indian Civil Society, intellectuals and the donors implicated with the alien conspiracy. Consequently, the state Emergency was imposed by the masterminds of those conspirators and empowered the illegal army-backed caretaker government in January 11, 2007. The illegal army-backed caretaker government was prevailed for two years.
 
The patriotic people came to know that who are the real traitors, betrayers, subservient and puppets of alien forces. They did many anti-state activities against country's interest by imposing illegal power as subservient of both US imperialism and Indian hegemony. As a result of their conspiracies, the alien forces empowered the grand alliance governemnt to implement their interests. The persons now in power and the groups of civil society are New Mir Jafors.
The present government adopted subservient foreign policies like the then 1/11 government to the alien forces such as formation of Anti-terrorist South Asian Task force with USA and India, TIFA treaty with USA, giving corridors to India in the name of Asian High Way and giving opportunity to the US to set up their naval camps on the plea of building deep sea-port in the Bay of Bengal etc. Moreover, the marciless killings at Pilkhana, harrassment of some NSI officers with 10-arm's haul case without any cause despite the implication of Indian insurgents in this case astonished the people. In this way, the independence, sovereignty and Islamic values may be destabilised due to the anti-state activities of the government and New Mir Jaffors in the name of Pro-US and Pro-Indian intellectuals of Civil Society.
 
The government should give up these activities and should give the priority over the country's interest. So we have to realise that the Plassey can reiterate over the country and destabilise our sovereignty, independence and Islamic values. So, it is the duty of all to forge a greater national unity and defend our independence and sovereignty with the lesson from Plassey.
 



__._,_.___


[* Moderator's Note - CHOTTALA is a non-profit, non-religious, non-political and non-discriminatory organization.

* Disclaimer: Any posting to the CHOTTALA are the opinion of the author. Authors of the messages to the CHOTTALA are responsible for the accuracy of their information and the conformance of their material with applicable copyright and other laws. Many people will read your post, and it will be archived for a very long time. The act of posting to the CHOTTALA indicates the subscriber's agreement to accept the adjudications of the moderator]




Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe

__,_._,___

[chottala.com] Please sign the petition for Immigration reform



Dear all,
 
There is a very important immigration bill is going to US Senate pretty soon for approval. This law will help lot of immigrant people like us.  I personally know lot of US people from Bangladesh are suffreing due to not having a good family immigration law.  Please follow the following link and send a message to help to pass this Family Act Reunion law. Your support is needed and truely appreciated.
 
Thanks
 

http://www.reformimmigrationforamerica.org

Hotmail® has ever-growing storage! Don't worry about storage limits. Check it out.

__._,_.___


[* Moderator's Note - CHOTTALA is a non-profit, non-religious, non-political and non-discriminatory organization.

* Disclaimer: Any posting to the CHOTTALA are the opinion of the author. Authors of the messages to the CHOTTALA are responsible for the accuracy of their information and the conformance of their material with applicable copyright and other laws. Many people will read your post, and it will be archived for a very long time. The act of posting to the CHOTTALA indicates the subscriber's agreement to accept the adjudications of the moderator]




Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe

__,_._,___

[chottala.com] Re: [khabor.com] Lesson from Plassey - Zia vs Zafar [MBI Munshi revisited]



Dear Mr. Aslam,


That is a fake and fabricated write-up. I never wrote such an article. This is the third time in 4 years that this article has appeared in my name. It has been circulated by RAW to discredit me and the BNP. I disown it and its contents and reject any association with it.

 

Regards

 

MBI Munshi





On Wed, Jun 24, 2009 at 8:44 PM, Syed Aslam <syed.aslam3@gmail.com> wrote:
Lesson from Plassey - Zia vs Zafar
[Barrister MBI Munshi's writeup  revisited]
 
Zia vs Zafar

Monday October 24 2005 23:08:53 PM BDT
MBI Munshi, Bangladesh
First published in "News rom Bangladesh":
http://www.bangladesh-web.com/view.php?hidRecord=67716

Nabab Siraj was not an excellent ruler; East India Company and their collaborators publicized him as an eccentric autocrat. He could not save his grandfather's kingdom from the British merchants. He was too lenient to the merchants and too naïve about their intention. Ultimately, his naiveté and lenience paid off. He lost his kingdom and life; Bangla lost its independence. After 100 years of bad publicity by British and their local collaborators he cam back in the pages of history as a symbol of our independence; a symbol of our lost pride.




__._,_.___


[* Moderator's Note - CHOTTALA is a non-profit, non-religious, non-political and non-discriminatory organization.

* Disclaimer: Any posting to the CHOTTALA are the opinion of the author. Authors of the messages to the CHOTTALA are responsible for the accuracy of their information and the conformance of their material with applicable copyright and other laws. Many people will read your post, and it will be archived for a very long time. The act of posting to the CHOTTALA indicates the subscriber's agreement to accept the adjudications of the moderator]




Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe

__,_._,___

[chottala.com] Re: [khabor.com] Lesson from Plassey - Zia vs Zafar [MBI Munshi revisited]



Lesson from Plassey - Zia vs Zafar
[Barrister MBI Munshi's writeup  revisited]
 
Zia vs Zafar

Monday October 24 2005 23:08:53 PM BDT
MBI Munshi, Bangladesh
First published in "News rom Bangladesh":
http://www.bangladesh-web.com/view.php?hidRecord=67716

Nabab Siraj was not an excellent ruler; East India Company and their collaborators publicized him as an eccentric autocrat. He could not save his grandfather's kingdom from the British merchants. He was too lenient to the merchants and too naïve about their intention. Ultimately, his naiveté and lenience paid off. He lost his kingdom and life; Bangla lost its independence. After 100 years of bad publicity by British and their local collaborators he cam back in the pages of history as a symbol of our independence; a symbol of our lost pride.

Modern propaganda ministers and pet historians also publicized Sheikh Mujib as a bad ruler too. People thought everything would be solved automatically after the independence, denying the fact that nation building is a long term tedious job. No nation has been developed until several decades of independence. Modern day Robert Clive, Jagat Shetth, Rajballav, etc. were working behind the scene.

Eventually Mujib was pushed to establish a totalitarian system BAKSHAL; even though he said, "if my people don't like it, I will revert" in a speech. General Zia wrote an article in Daily Bichitra supporting BAKSHAL. Despite being a lenient ruler he will be in the pages of history as he led the nation to independence. His vigorous stance for Bangalee rights amidst Paki generals' red eyes will keep in the pages of history as a super hero.

The independence lost through Siraj's defeat in 1757 was gained back by Mujib's rigid struggle for "six-point demands," win in 1970 election, unbending negotiation tactics with Paki dictators and finally the Liberation War.

Siraj's death led to a dark era of colonial rule. Mujib's death prompted a U-turn from the spirit of liberation and eventually brought the War Criminals and religion traders to power. From a plural secular nation the U-turn took us back to a backward nation that is longing for 7th century style theocracy; that is intolerant to minorities (Hindus, Kadianis, etc.). Now the country is heading for a Taleban style revolution.

The British merchants and their local collaborators like Jagat Shetth, Raj Ballabh gong and their successors, denigrated Siraj for a century after 1757. Mustaq-Zia- Ershad-Golam gong blacked out Mujib from Bangladesh for a long time after 1975. Siraj's killer Miran, backed by British and Mir Zafar, never faced justice for killing the Nabab. Mujib's killers, backed and rewarded by Mustaq- Zia- Ershad-Khaleeda gong escaped justice too.

There are several analogies between Mir Zafar Ali Khan and General Ziaur Rahman.

1. Mir Zafar acquired the Army Chief position by his good service to Murshid Kuli Khan. General Zia acquired Army Chief of Staff position by good job, as a sector commander, announcer of independence in liberation war, and afterwards serving Sheikh Mujibs government. Even appraising BAKSAL.

2. Mir Zafar was personally a religious and honest man and was popular at his time. But, he let the British and Hindu merchants virtually loot the country. Ziaur Rahman was a financially honest man and popular, but was dishonest in every other respect. All his ministers were corrupt and some patronized dacoits like Imdu, Galkata Kamal; they virtually looted the country.

3. Mir Zafar was the chief of Siraj's army. General Zia was a senior general at Mujib's time and Chief of Staff at the time of 1975 carnage.

4. Mir Zafar remained inactive when Jagat Shetth, Raj Ballabh, and British merchants defeated Nabab. Ziaur Rahman remained inactive when Faruk-Rashid-Mushtaq gong killed Mujib, his family, and the leaders of liberation war. [killer Farooq's clime, Bangladesh a Legacy of Blood. Zia's response was "don't come to me if you fail" (what a subidhabadi!)].

5. Mir Zafar awarded the Jagat Shetth, Raj Ballabh, and British merchants afterwards, when he came to power. General Zia awarded Farooq and Rashid Bangladesh Embassies in different countries after he came to power. He rewarded the razakars and gong for their loyalty to Paki colonialists and war criminals.

6. Mir Zafar kept silent when Miran killed Siraj. General Zia kept silent when his officers (later he made them ambassadors) killed Sheikh Mujib and leaders in the Jail.

7. Mir Zafar let Miran escape punishment. General Zia let Farooq-Rashid gong escape justice. Zia amended the constitution to save the killers (the black Indemnity Ordinance).

8. Mir Zafar's treason led the death of liberation itself leading to a colonial rule for centuries. Zia's treason led the death of spirits of liberation finally taking War Criminals and traitors to power. The country is now heading towards being a black shadow of Pakistan and Talebans.

9. Siraj was hated by the subsequent regimes like Mir Zafar and British rulers. Mujib is also blacked-out by the subsequent regimes like Zia, Ershad, Khaleda.

10. Mir Zafar demolished "monarchy" and promoted "colonialism", both existing in many underdeveloped countries then. General Zia demolished totalitarian BAKSHAL and promoted "militarism", both existing in many underdeveloped countries at his time. His election fiasco made world records.

11. Mir Zafar promoted treason, letting the Englishmen take power. He was finally hunted down by his own creation- treason. General Zia promoted killing and assassination by adopting "Indemnity Ordinance" in the constitution, freeing the punished war criminals from jails, freeing "seven murder" convict from jail, taking 11 murder convict to Hizbul Bahar, appointing the killers of Mujib in different Embassies, creating musclemen on campus. He was finally hunt down by his own creation – treason and killing. The brutality of his killing reflected his own ruthlessness towards any dissent.

12. Mir Zafar let East Indian Company loot the country. Zia let goons and thugs loot the country. He created hundreds of bank loan defaulters by forcing banks to lend money to his party goons. He took young talents and notorious killers in the same ship "Hizbu Bahar" together and taught them evade taxes. He also freed 2 thousand criminals from jails who were not only collaborators of Paki Junta, but also took part in killing, raping, looting, and torching freedom fighters.

MBI Munshi, Bangladesh
******************************
Sent by: Syed Aslam
[Note: Sender Syed Aslam, neither endorses nor contradicts the views expressed
          by our erudite blogger Barrister MBI Munshi. It is up to the readers to comment.
          Barrister Munshi is the author of a recently published book
           'The India Doctrine'

 My Photo 

Name: MBI Munshi
Location: Dhaka, Bangladesh
On Wed, Jun 24, 2009 at 9:11 AM, <bd_mailer@yahoo.com> wrote:


Lesson from Plassey

 
23rd June. The 252nd anniversary of Plassey Tragedy. This day is the mourning and pathetic day for patriotic nationalist and Pro-Islamic people. Plassey always encourages the people of our country to forge a solid-rocked national unity and defend the independence, sovereignty and Islamic values of our country. The hearts of the people trembled with fear while hearing the hollowness of Plassey. After the death of Nawab Ali Bardi Khan, his beloved grandson Siraj-ud-dowla ascended the throne and became the last independent Nawab of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa.
 
The young Nawab Siraj-ud-dowlah always tried to defend the independence of Bengal since his ascession to throne. His close relatives and royal servants could not accept him since his ascession. Some plotters injected conspiracy to dethrone him at the Qasim Bazaar Kuthi. Of them Ghasheti Begum, Raja Raj Ballabh, Raydurlabh, Jagatsheth, Raja Krishna Ballabh, Manik Chand, Amir chand, Amir Beg, Khadim Hossein, Yar Latif Khan, Watson and Commander-in-chief Mir Jafar Ali Khan were the plotters. Moreover, some exclusive Hindu government employees and Brahminist Hindu Zam-indars dissatisfied with Nawab Siraj-ud-dowlah and implicated with the plotters to dethone him.
 
At a moment, a hostility was created between Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah and the British East India company focusing to fortify the Fort William in Calcutta.
The East India Company accomplished to fortify the Fort William disparaging the decree of Nawab. Therefore, Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah invaded Calcutta and conquered the Fort William. After that, the East India Company rescued the Fort William and Joined with the Plotters to dethrone Nawab Siraj-ud-|Dowlah. At a moment, a treaty was singed between Mir Jafar and Robert Clive to make Mir Jafar the puppet Nawab of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa.
Once Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah decided to fight with the alien East India Company on the battlefield of Plassey. He caused to take an oath with Mir Jafar and others to fight with the East India Company touching the Holy Quran at any cost. But he could realise that Mir Jafar would betray him. In June 23, 1757 CE, both the Nawab's troops and Clives English troops were gathered near by the Bhagirathi river.
 
There were 57,000 native soldiers of Nawab's forces and there were 3000 English soldiers of Clive's forces. At a moment, a fierce battle was broken out. First, the cannons of Nawab forces were roared. Of 57,000 native forces, the commander-in-chief Mir Jafar, Jagat Sheth and their troops enjoyed the Battle standing on the battle field like puppet. The commander Mohanlal, Mir Mardan and French Commander Sinfrey fought valiantly to stem the British forces. We came to know that Jagat Sheth helped Clive's forces actively and joked with Mir Jafar sitting on an elephant. Once, Mir Jafar advised Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah to cease the battle and Nawab decreed to cease the battle believing Mir Jafar.
 
Before that, the English forces fled to the mango grove in the wake of strong resistance of Nawab's forces. After the ceasefire, the Nawab forces went to the tent. At that time Mir Jafar sent a letter to Robert Clive to raid on the Nawab's forces. Then, the British forces swooped down the Nawab's forces and Nowab's forces were diverted. At that time, Mir Mordan was martyred from the fire of Cannon.
 
Nawab Siraj-ud-Dowlah was defeated deplorably and helpless Nawab went to Murshidabad. Nawab Siraj-ud-Dollah started his journey to Patna by boat with his wife and daughter aimed at fighting with the British forces again to defend the independence. On the way of his jouney to Patna, he was nabbed by the forces of Mir Qasim at Bhaghwan gola and sent with his wife and daughter to Murshidabad. He was detained at a closet of Zafargonj. The betrayer Mir Jafar became the Puppet Nawab of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa by the help of British forces. Both Clive and Miron, the son of Mir Jafar selected Mohammadi Beg to assassinate Nawab Siraj. Mohammadi Beg assassinated Nawab Sirajud-dowlah in July 2, 1757 CE. Thus, Bangladesh as well as the Sub continent was subjugated by the British rulers for two-hundred years. With the continuous struggle after Plassey, Bangladesh got her aspiring independence through the war of liberation of 1971. So, we can teach lesson from Plassey, if we cannot defend our freedom and sovereignty, we will have to bear another threat like Plassey.
 
Despite achieving independence, the cluches of vultures have fallen on our country yet as well as we are victimised of alien aggression. Here is some references i.e., the US imperialists intend to set up their military camp in our country, the Indian hegemonists are also directing their water aggressions on our rivers such as turning our lands of the country into a desertification with building both Farakka and Tipaimukh Dam. But some new Mir Jafars keep silence. After that both the US imperialists and Indian hegemonists are plotting to sway over Bangladesh for a long time. Some so-called Pro-US and Pro-Indian Civil Society, intellectuals and the donors implicated with the alien conspiracy. Consequently, the state Emergency was imposed by the masterminds of those conspirators and empowered the illegal army-backed caretaker government in January 11, 2007. The illegal army-backed caretaker government was prevailed for two years.
 
The patriotic people came to know that who are the real traitors, betrayers, subservient and puppets of alien forces. They did many anti-state activities against country's interest by imposing illegal power as subservient of both US imperialism and Indian hegemony. As a result of their conspiracies, the alien forces empowered the grand alliance governemnt to implement their interests. The persons now in power and the groups of civil society are New Mir Jafors.
The present government adopted subservient foreign policies like the then 1/11 government to the alien forces such as formation of Anti-terrorist South Asian Task force with USA and India, TIFA treaty with USA, giving corridors to India in the name of Asian High Way and giving opportunity to the US to set up their naval camps on the plea of building deep sea-port in the Bay of Bengal etc. Moreover, the marciless killings at Pilkhana, harrassment of some NSI officers with 10-arm's haul case without any cause despite the implication of Indian insurgents in this case astonished the people. In this way, the independence, sovereignty and Islamic values may be destabilised due to the anti-state activities of the government and New Mir Jaffors in the name of Pro-US and Pro-Indian intellectuals of Civil Society.
 
The government should give up these activities and should give the priority over the country's interest. So we have to realise that the Plassey can reiterate over the country and destabilise our sovereignty, independence and Islamic values. So, it is the duty of all to forge a greater national unity and defend our independence and sovereignty with the lesson from Plassey.
 





__._,_.___


[* Moderator's Note - CHOTTALA is a non-profit, non-religious, non-political and non-discriminatory organization.

* Disclaimer: Any posting to the CHOTTALA are the opinion of the author. Authors of the messages to the CHOTTALA are responsible for the accuracy of their information and the conformance of their material with applicable copyright and other laws. Many people will read your post, and it will be archived for a very long time. The act of posting to the CHOTTALA indicates the subscriber's agreement to accept the adjudications of the moderator]




Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe

__,_._,___