Banner Advertise

Wednesday, July 15, 2009

[chottala.com] Language followed theoris of two nations- Not correct



As dina khan says:

My searching was for trialing war criminals. The reasons of war in 1971 were seeded in 1947 division of Bengal as well as divisions of India.

My searching is also to establish social justice & lawful humanity & human right for doing trials of 1971 war criminals it needs to find out the real criminals who were responsible to create the situation of the 1971 war.

It was certainly the theory of 2 Nations for 2 Languages Hindi & Urdu for 2 Nations India & Pakistan.

Mr. Jinnah who was the Iron man after creation of Pakistan declared that Urdu only Urdu will be the state language of Pakistan according to the theory of 2 nations for 2 Languages Hindi & Urdu as Hindi is the state language of India. So Urdu is for Pakistan.  He is correct...

There was no chance for Bengali national or Bengali language or other provincial languages in the theory of 2 Nations for 2 Languages.

Now for doing proper lawful trialing why should not be called them who were responsible of establishing theory of 2 nations for 2 languages?.

 

Dear dina khan,

Your searching for trial of war criminals and your further idea as you told of war in 1971 were seeded in 1947 division of Bengal as well as divisions of India. No, not like this. It was seeded on that very day of 1952 when M.A. Jinnah declared urdu and only urdu will be the state language. He was absolutely wrong and that is why Bengali people disregarded his proposal hatefully and did never abide by his wrong decision. Pakistan was not created on the basis of language. Yes dina khan you cannot say  "there was no chance for Bengali national or Bengali language or other provincial languages in the theory of 2 Nations for 2 Languages". That means urdu of minority Urdu speaking people coming from Bihars should be our prvincial languages. Really a funny idea indeed. 

 

Two nation theory was based on the Muslims and Hindus. I repeat on the basis of religion only not on languages. M.A Jinnah along with three other iron men from East Bengal like H.S. Sohrawardy, A.K.M.Fazlul Hoque and  Moulana Bhashani  whom M.A.Jinnah always used to get by his side as his strong compatriots whereas in Pakistan except Liakat Ali Khan no other leaders were traceable  by his side fought for the separate country for Muslims in the whole of united India.

 

The majority of Muslim population which constitutes maximum Bengali Muslims from East Pakistan and some from West Pakistann whose active role later on created Pakistan as a separate Muslim country. History says little or no mention about the role of  urdu speaking Biharis of India took part in the creation of Pakistan. They wanted to take the fruits of Independence for which majority of Muslims in Bengal sacrificed their lives, and even so many times were entangled  in hindu Muslims riots both in Kolkata and in East Bengal before and even after 1947. When everything was settled then these urdu speaker non Bengali Biharis with loin cloth and a bag on their shoulder  entered in the then East Pakistan (Bangladesh) of their own accord. After entering in our country their first and foremost  claim is to establish urdu languages as the state language and tried to dominate over the real sons of the soil the Bengali people. They tried to remind two nation theory every now and then on language basis only.

 

Was M.A.Jinnah ever succesful in his wrong step in establishlng urdu over the people of East Pakistan any time since his declaration in 1952? Then why now the question of language arise again and again with two nation theory when our Bengali people living peacefully in their own land?  Again in this regard I like to quote, Nathuram Godsay a strong follower of Mahatma Gandhi after killing Mahatma Gandhi when asked he answered he could not tolerate as Gandhi aggreed and gave away half of India to Muslims and never utter gave half of India to  urdu speaking Bihari people.  What you are seeing now, Bengali language is now the full fledged established language in our Bangladesh and no place of urdu any more and is completely wiped out along with those trouble maker Biharis as "dud mey se makki nikalke fekh dia".

 

Trial of war criminals in Bangladesh are their own headache not involving any outsiders like non Bengali urdu speaking Biharis though they were also similarly responsible as war criminals as killers of our Bengali people in our own soils, then why to think as you are telling "laws  also to establish social justice & lawful humanity & human right for doing trials of 1971 war criminals it needs to find out the real criminals who were responsible to create the situation of the 1971 war". Real criminal already established from our own who accelerated the atrocities and took part in killing of our people in 1971 and our Bangladesh govt want their trials only.

 

 

The people of the then East Bengal later on East Pakistan and now Bangladesh gave their maximum votes and supports for the creation of separate Muslim country as  Pakistan which M.A. Jinnah even did not get so much supports from West Pakistan at that time. Frontier province consists of different group and Kabila like Waziri, Bitany, Afridi and Masudi did not support for the creation of Pakistan. In those frontier province of Pathan majority Kabail Elaka or Gair Elaka as they use to tell themselves, of which posthu speaking don't like to obey the laws of Pakistan yet. They are ruling their frontier area by making their own Jirga system. Even those people in the same Pakistan don't like to talk in urdu or any other languages except their own posthu or Pakthun language.

 

Is it not wise dina khan to avoid talking  about two nation theory on language basis only which is absolutely absurd now a days.

 

Dowllah.

 



Internet Explorer 8 makes surfing easier. Get it now!

__._,_.___


[* Moderator's Note - CHOTTALA is a non-profit, non-religious, non-political and non-discriminatory organization.

* Disclaimer: Any posting to the CHOTTALA are the opinion of the author. Authors of the messages to the CHOTTALA are responsible for the accuracy of their information and the conformance of their material with applicable copyright and other laws. Many people will read your post, and it will be archived for a very long time. The act of posting to the CHOTTALA indicates the subscriber's agreement to accept the adjudications of the moderator]




Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe

__,_._,___