We must be pragmatic, our national interest
must take precedence over everything else. We have to
weigh the pros and cons before deciding on any issue
rather than being dictated by our heart. we should be
dictated by our head. I feel that we have everything
to gain by recognising Israel and nothing to gain by
with holding recognition. Do you realise that the
favorable publicity that we will get from the world
press dominated by the jews. This will help our
country greatly in advancing forward economically.
Even Arab countries have diplomatic relation
with Israel so if we recognise Israel it will not be
seen grudgingly by Arab and Islamic countries.
Salahuddin Ayubi
--- "Md. Aminul Islam" <aminul_islam_raj@yahoo.com>
wrote:
> Our neighbering India has very good relation with
> Isrel.In our country there are many followers of
> Indian policy.And we know both of the two are in
> war against Islam and Muslim in the name of
> fighting "terrorism'.We have some so called hired
> JIBIS who may want this,But people of Bangladesh
> will never even consider the question.So it is' void
> abinitio.'
> Rather people of Bangladesh want to see the
> abolition of the illigal inhuman country.
>
> S A Hannan <sahannan@sonarbangladesh.com> wrote:
> As some quartes are raising the issue, I
> am forwarding myearlier article on the issue
>
> Bangladesh Should not Recognize Recognize Israil
>
>
> Shah Abdul Hannan*
>
>
>
> The Foreign Minister of Pakistan, a few days back,
> met the Israeli Foreign Minister in Istanbul. This
> has brought to light that Pakistan was negotiating
> secretly with Israel for quite a long time. The
> major political parties and alliances of Pakistan,
> namely Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarian
> (Benzir Bhutto), Pakistan Muslim League (Newaz
> Sharif), Muttahida Majlis Amal (MMA) and ARD called
> a nation-wide strike in protest of the meeting by
> Pakistan’s Foreign Minister with Israeli
Foreign
> Minister.. Press reports suggest that the strike was
> successfully observed. The opposition in Pakistan
> immediately after this meeting sat together and
> formed a committee to decide the future course in
> view of the action of the government.
>
> In this backdrop, a few of our newspaper
> columnists have demanded that Bangladesh should
> recognize Israel. About two years back a section of
> the leaders of our business community demanded that
> Israel be recognized. The Chamber leaders raised the
> demand because at that time some US Congressmen
> demanded that the entry of Bangladeshi product in
> the US market be linked with Bangladesh recognition
> of Israel. The demand of the US Congressman alarmed
> a section of our businessmen. Being panicked they
> demanded that Israel be recognized. But they did not
> seriously ponder how Bangladesh-United States
> bilateral relations are linked with Bangladesh
> recognition of Israel?
>
> Thereafter, about a year back, in an indoor
> meeting of a Think Tank that was attended by
> journalists, retired army officers, geo-strategic
> and security analysts in which this writer was
> present the issue of the Bangladesh recognition of
> Israel was discussed. A senior journalist present in
> the meeting tried to convince why Israel should be
> recognized. It became apparent that some other
> gentlemen present in the meeting supported his view.
> In another meeting, a few days back, this writer
> observed that Pakistan’s regotiation with
Israel was
> discussed and two or three persons expressed their
> view in favor of Bangladesh recognition of Israel.
>
>
> This makes it clear that a section of the elite
> of our society is in favor of Bangladesh recognition
> of Israel. To them it is not a matter of
> consideration that Israel is an illegitimate state
> that has violated many UN resolutions and occupied
> two-thirds of the Palestine land using force has
> occupied East Jerusalem that does not belong to
> them. If for argument sake we accept that Israel is
> the rightful owner of the land which UN mandate has
> given them in 1948 and should be under Israeli
> control, even then Israel should have vacated East
> Jerusalem long before. Israel has illegally
> established hundreds of settlements in West Bank
> Israel also established such settlements in Gaza
> that Israel vacated only recently. We have seen in
> the television screen their pain and anguish, as
> they had to leave Gaza which was not their land.
> This is nothing compared to the inhuman brutality
> the Palestinian had to suffer in their own land at
> the hands of the state of Israel.
>
> People in our country who are supporting the
> recognition of Israel by Bangladesh, to them these
> are of no consequence, value and consideration. They
> ignore the fact that Israel is still denying
> Palestinian full control over the sky and sea of
> Gaza. They are not ready to consider all these
> issues. They are taking a very simplistic attitude.
> They are not considering the fact that only 5-7
> countries out of the 57 Muslim countries have
> diplomatic relations with Israel and the reasons are
> also known. Turkey recognized Israel for it’s
the
> then government leaders were very friendly with the
> West. Egypt recognized Israel to recover Sinai
> Peninsula from military occupation. No doubt it was
> a wrong decision on the part of the then Egyptian
> leadership, but still one can find some logic in it.
> Egypt was forced by circumstances. Moreover, the
> Egyptian people had no role in this decision for an
> undemocratic autocratic head of state ruled the
> country. This is also true of Jordan.
> Most of the countries of the Muslim World have not
> yet recognized Israel and still now are opposed to
> such a move.
>
> Now the question is how recognizing Israel will
> benefit Bangladesh? If there was really great
> benefit we could think over the matter. How big is
> Israel? It is a small country of a few thousand
> square miles, roughly one-tenth of Bangladesh or
> less. The total population of Israel is 4 millions
> approximately. The question then naturally arises
> how big is the Israeli market from which we can
> benefit by exporting and also how much Bangladesh is
> losing for not having trade with Israel? How much we
> can earn from this small market? As regards imports,
> really what Israel can specially offer us that we
> cannot procure from other sources? Shall we have to
> import computers and other scientific equipments
> from Israel? Shall we have to import any other
> hardware or software from Israel? Shall we have to
> import aircraft and armaments from Israel? Are these
> not available in other countries? Whatever we need
> are available in China, Russia, United States,
> Malaysia, Indonesia and Pakistan.
> Then what is the big reason that we have to import
> from Israel, a country with which we do not have
> trade since 1947? How the scenario has changed or
> how far the situation is positively developed that
> Bangladesh needs to recognize Israel? We must not
> forget that the illegal state of Israel was created
> by a resolution of UN in 1948 when the number of
> member countries was 50-55, most of whom were from
> Europe, America and Latin America. The number of UN
> member countries from Asia and Africa then were few
> in number. Who are then the other UN member
> countries? Pakistan and India then just got
> independence from the British colonial yoke and have
> become UN members. Still then Pakistan opposed the
> 1948 UN resolution that created the state of Israel.
> India also opposed the resolution. It is thus clear
> that Israel is an illegitimate state that the West
> imposed on the indigenous Arabs and Palestinians
> through the then UN because Asia and Africa, the
> two big continents, were not
> represented fully in the then UN membership. The
> West got the 1948 UN resolution passed, created
> Israel by sheer strength of membership and votes.
> We must not forget that the resolution was
> essentially illegal and therefore unlawful. The
> Muslim countries only surrendered to de facto
> situation and ground realities. But the truth is
> that there should have been one country only in the
> old Palestine, that is Palestine. There was no
> state named Israel in the region before 1948 UN
> resolution . This resolution created a new state
> with new boundaries. Jews from all over the world
> was made to immigrate to Israel and new settlements
> were raised there. Since then Israel occupied more
> Palestinian territories and expanded its boundary by
> deceit, use of military force and war and uprooted
> the local Palestinians and made them refugees.
> Israel occupied the whole of Palestine in 1967 war.
> Since then 38 years have passed.
>
> There is no moral basis for the creation of the
> state of Israel. It has been given legitimacy by use
> of force. Martial Law has no moral basis. Likewise,
> Israel has no moral basis although it gained some
> sort of legitimacy because of the UN resolution of
> 1948. This illegal state is still not allowing the
> Palestinians to have their own state in the land of
> which only they are the rightful owner. Israel is
> not returning Jerusalem to the Palestinians who are
> its rightful claimant. Israel is not allowing the
> Palestinian refugees to return to their homeland.
> Many such problems still exist and yet to be
> resolved. In such situation, why should Bangladesh
> recognize Israel? What has happened that Bangladesh
> needs to recognize an illegal state? Is it justified
> to recognize Israel as long as Palestinians does not
> recognize Israel? Yes, if the independent and
> sovereign state of Palestine is created and state of
> Palestine recognizes Israel, we shall then recognize
> state of Israel.
> Israel is not big as United States. It is not that
> big as European Union. The Israeli market is also
> not as big as EU and US. The question of
> substantial economic loss for having no trade and
> diplomatic relations is therefore not tenable. Is
> the demand of recognizing Israel is based on justice
> and in the interest of Islam? Unfortunately these
> reasons are not getting due attention of our elite.
> Why?
=== message truncated ===
Send instant messages to your online friends http://uk.messenger.yahoo.com
[* Moderator's Note - CHOTTALA is a non-profit, non-religious, non-political and non-discriminatory organization.
* Disclaimer: Any posting to the CHOTTALA are the opinion of the author. Authors of the messages to the CHOTTALA are responsible for the accuracy of their information and the conformance of their material with applicable copyright and other laws. Many people will read your post, and it will be archived for a very long time. The act of posting to the CHOTTALA indicates the subscriber's agreement to accept the adjudications of the moderator]
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/chottala/
<*> Your email settings:
Individual Email | Traditional
<*> To change settings online go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/chottala/join
(Yahoo! ID required)
<*> To change settings via email:
mailto:chottala-digest@yahoogroups.com
mailto:chottala-fullfeatured@yahoogroups.com
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
chottala-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
