If Bashkali Tragedy was dacoity, why the criminals are not punished yet ?
Is there a cover-up by some powerful people?
WRT:
Ms Dina Khan
What are you talking about .......?
Do you still have questions in your mind that Hindus in
Bangladesh are a minority religious group?
Is not Islam a distinctly different religion than that of
Hinduism?
Have a reality check ....
Today's Bangladesh has a constitutionally declared
State Religion which is Islam...As such, the Hindus may be
deemed as second class citizens, according to many ...
Just because there is no seperate electorate for the Hindus
and the Muslims both in India and in Bangladesh does not
mean that communalism and persecution of religious
minorities is totally absent.
The communalism thrieves on social backwardness, fanaticism,
and narrow vested secterian interest, sometimes political
interest.
Please read the news item on the seminar organized
by DORP again:
before you continue to give further twist on the issue under discussion.
My point was "Mr. Siraj uddowllah brought Gujrat Incident out of context
which definitely had a communal undertone.
On the Bashkhali Tragedy your mentor Mr. Siraj uddowllah has every
right to pass his opinion & present his points of views "as a human right activist"
However, the seminar in question presented a different perspective.
It was organized by Developmental Organization of the Rural Poor [DORP].
The Deputy Speaker of Bangladesh Parliament, Mr. Shawkat Ali,
emphasized that proclaiming a particular religion as the State Religion
undermines other religions in the country.
According to the news item, Mr. Shayamol Dutta was only a key note speaker,
who mentioned that in 1947-division was based on communalism ....that
communalism created divisions among the people, the minorities (religious)
have become aliens in their own land ......the ramnants of communalism still
exist ....
The other speakers also expressed their concerns on the disturbance
of communal harmony in our country.
As we all know, the culprits of the Bashkhali killings has not
yet been punished. According to the lone surviving member of the
victim-family Bimol Sheel, the criminals are now roaming freely ...
Is there a cover-up attempt to hide the crime? Why?
If Bashkali Tragedy was a dacoity case, why the criminals are not
punished yet ? Is there some "powerful people" behind the docoity?
Should not these criminals be given examplary punishment for
burning 11 people to death? Six years have already passed.....
I still wonder why Mr. Shayamol Dutta is being singled out by yourself
[Ms Dina Khan] and Mr. Siraj uddowllah for arranging the conference,
although the conference was arranged by an organization called Developmental
Organization of the Rural Poor [DORP].
Again, Ms Dina Khan you are saying:
"Mr Aslam Are you acting for cmmunal Raw? "
Can you explain you statement and tell us how do relate
your hypothesis with the issue under discussion.
Is that the only "LOGIC" you have?
Syed Aslam
Attention Mr. Syed Aslam
You are forgetting the root of the point.
Why the Hindus are being called the minority people in Bangladesh??
Is not Bangladesh a country of secular democracy?
Are the Hindus in Bangladesh casting their votes separately as minority people?
& Have they separate administration in Bangladesh as minority??
Why the Muslims in India are being called the minority people in India?
Is not India a democratic Secular country??
Are the Muslims in India casting their votes separately as minority people? & Have they separate administration In India as Muslims are minority people??
Answer is. < NO>
Why did Mr. Symol Dutta being an editor of a news paper & others being as human right activists call a round table conference in the name of minority community insecure in Bangladesh?
Are they not creating communal feeling & communal situation by holding such of talking & meeting or conference ?
It was better for ( them ) the editors of news (NEWS means News of north east west south) papers & for the so called human right activists to think for dicussing as a whole what are the reasons what are the back ground behind that for happening such type accidents at any where in Bangladesh & at other part of the world including India.
But they had done it as communal activists not as an editor or as human right activists
Mr. Dowlla has passed his opinion as a human right activist not creating communal feeling.
Mr Aslam Are you acting for cmmunal Raw?
From: Syed Aslam <Syed.Aslam3@ gmail.com>
Subject: Re: [chottala.com] A family of Hindus in Bashkali were the victims of dacoity and not a reparcation of Guzrat incidents.
To:
chottala@yahoogroup s.com
Received: Thursday, 24 September, 2009, 1:31 AM
Dear All
Mr. Siraj uddowllah brought Gujrat Incident out of context in his original
blamed Mr. Shayamol Dutta for not arranging a conference on Guzrat
when there was a massacre of Muslims.
Mr. Siraj uddowlah went further to request the Bhorer Kagoj
owner Mr. Saber H. Chowdhuri to take action this one eyed
hindu editor . {anything personal ????? ]
Now, Mr. uddowllah is changing his stance.....: ::
He mentions that Bashkhali horror was a case of docoity.
The tragic Bashkhali incident could be very well be the acts
of some miscreants who are docoits..... .
Mr. uddowllah should have mentioned that in the first place instead
of bringing Norendra Modi and Guzrat riots while discussing the
conference arranged by DORP.
Now, in his present post Mr. Siraj uddowllah says " A family of Hindus in
Bashkali were the victims of dacoity and not a reparcation of
Guzrat incidents."
Many people have indicated the incident as communal matter, which
may be debatable, but I have not seen anyone calling the Bashkhali
tragedy a "reparcation of Guzrat incident ".
Can Mr. Siraj uddowllah point out where did someone has called the
Bashkhali Tragedy as the repurcation of Guzrat incident?
As far as I have seen Mr. Siraj uddowllah is the only person who brought
Guzrat massacre while talking about Bashkhali incident ...
I only objected to his bringing up the issue of Gujrat Riots while
discussing an tragic incident at home. Mr. Siraj uddowllah's accusation
in chottala message # 10390 is misleading and totally unfounded.
There is no mix up in my position.... we should not just bring incidents
in India or any other country, out of context explicitly or implicitly, while
discussing a tragic incident in Bangladesh.
Mr. Siraj uddowllah is at liberty to discuss & condemn
Norendro Modi's crimes and Massacre of Muslims in a different
thread .... But, blaming Mr. Shayamol Dutta for not holding a
conference on Gujrat riot has definitely given his post a vivid
communal.undertone ....... there is an attitude problem that
thrieves on innuendoes ....
There is no denying of the fact that there are many "pockets" in
Bangladesh where minorities, including the Hindus are soft targets
of the criminals, docoits and the land grabbers ......
Thanks for everyone's patience.
Syed Aslam