I am sure no one wants people, specially women and children, to die because of a silly war. It's so easy for persons like to you to support waging a war in comfort of your home. The endless suffering of the people of Palestine is unbearable, therefore this silly war should stop. One side alone cannot a war and both sides must agree.
History is history, whether one accepts it or not. You have not quoted a single instance where I was wrong, instead of writing out your irrate mind why not give a few facts and we can debate on it.
Kind regards.
To: chottala@yahoogroups.com
From:
Date: Tue, 13 Jan 2009 06:28:03 +0000
Subject: [chottala.com] Re: BOYCOTT ISRAEL and Palestine
I m very much sorry to say that lost dream (sorry no name) should
know about the history a little bit more!
Is this the history of Israel! a country!
hope readers will try to get the real point of view. this type of
mail only shows us the way to moderate the history.
lost dream tried to illustrate a history of thousand years. But Jews
were not centered only at Palestine! All over the world who were
followers of Prophet Musa(sm) were Jews. the history will show u how
Jews betrayed in every phase of history.
it is a big deal to let u know about the history of Jews. it is
matter of time also. it is very much tough for me to write the whole
history of Jews in respect of your moderated history.
but dear chottala readers. don't be confused. it is always shame full
to kill human being. but Israel! they create the killers. they use
other to committed crime.
read the history, analyze it, try to get the original history. it is
not very much hard to get it, it is available, but some people trying
to moderate it. be aware of those people. let other people know about
it.
With best wishes for all Palestine people
Tanbir
--- In chottala@yahoogroups.com , Lost Dream <lostadream@...> wrote:
>
>
> It is nice that as Muslims, most of us give unconditional support
to the Palestinian cause and portray the suffering of innocent
children and women suffering from the Israel aggression. A few days
ago I was riding with a friend and he was driving, I was trying to
explain about the history of Israel and her creation. He became
extremely upset and nearly crashed the car because of my use of the
word "creation" instead of "occupation". It then dawned on me that
not only he but most of our young generation are too lazy and do not
bother to read and learn history instead they rely of "hearsay" and
believe what they hear. This is not only the case about
Israel/Palestine ( 3000 years) but also our own Bangladesh history
which is only 38 years.
>
> I would request all our intelligent readers and participants to
prove where I am wrong in the following:
>
> The history of Israel (including the area of Palestine) begins much
before the religion Christian or Muslim were established as
religions. 1300 years before the birth of Prophet Issa, Israel was
populated and ruled by Jews, they were escaping the Egyptian rulers.
Prophet Musa (Jewsish) and his followers roamed the Sinai desert for
forty years and reached Israel.
>
> Many rulers invaded and ruled that area since then and in the year
636 Caliph Abd-el-Malik took over Israel from the Byzantine Empire.
The Arabs ruled the area till 1099. In 1099 the Crusade, on a call
from the Pope in Rome, began. The crusade was made by Europeans and
they defeated the Arabs occupied Israel from 1099 to 1291. The Mamluk
dynasty (Islamic rulers) defeated the European Crusaders and took
over Israel in the year 1291 and ruled it till 1516.
> In the year 1516 the Ottoman empire (King Suleiman) took over
Israel and ruled it till 1918.
>
> After the second world war, 1946, the British government, with the
support of UN, created the Independent state of Israel for the Jews.
Then began the worldwide migration of Jews to Israel, their
population began to explode. The rich Jews began to purchase land
owned by local Muslims and slowly the Muslims began to be displaced
and replaced by Jews. As soon as "The State of Israel" was formed,
five Arab nations (Egypt, Syria, Jordan, Lebanon and Iraq attacked
Israel as these countries was against the formation of the State of
Israel. The Arab nations was subsequently defeated and the war became
the "War of Independence".
>
> For survival Israel fought the following wars:
>
> 1948: Independence War
> 1956: Sinai War
> 1967 Six Days War
> 1973: Yom Kippur War.
>
> In each of these wars Israel defeated the Arabs and occupied a vast
land area, even reached the banks of Suez Canal. Ultimately Israel
returned many occupied lands but retained some areas occupied.
>
> From the above it can be concluded that the dream of
Hamas, "destruction of Israel" and Iran's hope "wiping out Israel
from the Map" are all day dreams which are turning into a bad
nightmare, which will never happen.
>
> We feel sorry and understand the plight of the Palestine people, we
hope that they gain independence and govern themselves, but I do not
believe that by firing hundreds of improvised rockets into Israel
will defeat Israel instead their pitiful conditions will only get
worse. They should try and work together for peace. Forget their
dream "Destruction of Israel" instead say " Let us get independence
and learn to live together and civilized nations"
>
> So readers my point is "Innocent Women and Children" are
actually "Victims of a Stupid War".
>
> By giving unconditional support we are actually causing them more
misery, we all should help find a peaceful solution instead of
prolonged misery. Peace with some consideration is much better than
nothing at all. The days of Hercules and Golaihs are over a long time
ago.
>
> Kind regards.
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> __________________________________________________________
> Windows Live™ Hotmail®: Chat. Store. Share. Do more with mail.
> http://windowslive.com/explore?
ocid=TXT_TAGLM_WL_t1_hm_justgotbetter_explore_012009
>
know about the history a little bit more!
Is this the history of Israel! a country!
hope readers will try to get the real point of view. this type of
mail only shows us the way to moderate the history.
lost dream tried to illustrate a history of thousand years. But Jews
were not centered only at Palestine! All over the world who were
followers of Prophet Musa(sm) were Jews. the history will show u how
Jews betrayed in every phase of history.
it is a big deal to let u know about the history of Jews. it is
matter of time also. it is very much tough for me to write the whole
history of Jews in respect of your moderated history.
but dear chottala readers. don't be confused. it is always shame full
to kill human being. but Israel! they create the killers. they use
other to committed crime.
read the history, analyze it, try to get the original history. it is
not very much hard to get it, it is available, but some people trying
to moderate it. be aware of those people. let other people know about
it.
With best wishes for all Palestine people
Tanbir
--- In chottala@yahoogroup
>
>
> It is nice that as Muslims, most of us give unconditional support
to the Palestinian cause and portray the suffering of innocent
children and women suffering from the Israel aggression. A few days
ago I was riding with a friend and he was driving, I was trying to
explain about the history of Israel and her creation. He became
extremely upset and nearly crashed the car because of my use of the
word "creation" instead of "occupation"
not only he but most of our young generation are too lazy and do not
bother to read and learn history instead they rely of "hearsay" and
believe what they hear. This is not only the case about
Israel/Palestine ( 3000 years) but also our own Bangladesh history
which is only 38 years.
>
> I would request all our intelligent readers and participants to
prove where I am wrong in the following:
>
> The history of Israel (including the area of Palestine) begins much
before the religion Christian or Muslim were established as
religions. 1300 years before the birth of Prophet Issa, Israel was
populated and ruled by Jews, they were escaping the Egyptian rulers.
Prophet Musa (Jewsish) and his followers roamed the Sinai desert for
forty years and reached Israel.
>
> Many rulers invaded and ruled that area since then and in the year
636 Caliph Abd-el-Malik took over Israel from the Byzantine Empire.
The Arabs ruled the area till 1099. In 1099 the Crusade, on a call
from the Pope in Rome, began. The crusade was made by Europeans and
they defeated the Arabs occupied Israel from 1099 to 1291. The Mamluk
dynasty (Islamic rulers) defeated the European Crusaders and took
over Israel in the year 1291 and ruled it till 1516.
> In the year 1516 the Ottoman empire (King Suleiman) took over
Israel and ruled it till 1918.
>
> After the second world war, 1946, the British government, with the
support of UN, created the Independent state of Israel for the Jews.
Then began the worldwide migration of Jews to Israel, their
population began to explode. The rich Jews began to purchase land
owned by local Muslims and slowly the Muslims began to be displaced
and replaced by Jews. As soon as "The State of Israel" was formed,
five Arab nations (Egypt, Syria, Jordan, Lebanon and Iraq attacked
Israel as these countries was against the formation of the State of
Israel. The Arab nations was subsequently defeated and the war became
the "War of Independence"
>
> For survival Israel fought the following wars:
>
> 1948: Independence War
> 1956: Sinai War
> 1967 Six Days War
> 1973: Yom Kippur War.
>
> In each of these wars Israel defeated the Arabs and occupied a vast
land area, even reached the banks of Suez Canal. Ultimately Israel
returned many occupied lands but retained some areas occupied.
>
> From the above it can be concluded that the dream of
Hamas, "destruction of Israel" and Iran's hope "wiping out Israel
from the Map" are all day dreams which are turning into a bad
nightmare, which will never happen.
>
> We feel sorry and understand the plight of the Palestine people, we
hope that they gain independence and govern themselves, but I do not
believe that by firing hundreds of improvised rockets into Israel
will defeat Israel instead their pitiful conditions will only get
worse. They should try and work together for peace. Forget their
dream "Destruction of Israel" instead say " Let us get independence
and learn to live together and civilized nations"
>
> So readers my point is "Innocent Women and Children" are
actually "Victims of a Stupid War".
>
> By giving unconditional support we are actually causing them more
misery, we all should help find a peaceful solution instead of
prolonged misery. Peace with some consideration is much better than
nothing at all. The days of Hercules and Golaihs are over a long time
ago.
>
> Kind regards.
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> ____________
> Windows Live™ Hotmail®: Chat. Store. Share. Do more with mail.
> http://windowslive.
ocid=TXT_TAGLM_
>
Windows Live™ Hotmail®: Chat. Store. Share. Do more with mail. Check it out. __._,_.___
[* Moderator's Note - CHOTTALA is a non-profit, non-religious, non-political and non-discriminatory organization.
* Disclaimer: Any posting to the CHOTTALA are the opinion of the author. Authors of the messages to the CHOTTALA are responsible for the accuracy of their information and the conformance of their material with applicable copyright and other laws. Many people will read your post, and it will be archived for a very long time. The act of posting to the CHOTTALA indicates the subscriber's agreement to accept the adjudications of the moderator]
Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe
__,_._,___
