[Re: [notun_bangladesh] Now they want to accuse us as Communal ]
United Bengal proposal was made by Huseyn Shaheed Suhrawardy and Sarat Chandra Bose not Maolana Bashani
[ With all due respect to Maolana Bashani]
Mr. Md Mostafa Kamal
Are you re-writing the history? You are factually incorrect , your business as usual !
FYI:
The United Bengal proposal was the bid made by Bengali political leaders Huseyn Shaheed Suhrawardy and Sarat Chandra Bose to found a united and independent nation-state of in Bengal. The proposal was floated as an alternative to the partition of Bengal on communal lines. The initiative failed mainly due to the efforts of communal political Party Hindu Mohasovha.
"Maulana Bhasani moved to Ghagmara in Assam in the late 1930s to defend the interests of Bangali settlers there. He made his debut as a leader at Bhasan Char on the Brahmaputra river where he constructed an embankment with the co-operation of the Bangali settlers, thereby saving the peasants from the scourge of annual inundation. Relieved of the recurring floods the local people fondly started to call him Bhasani Saheb, an epithet by which the Maulana has been known from then on. In 1937 Bhasani joined the Assam Muslim League and became president of Assam unit of the party.
The Assam government made a law restricting Bangali settlement beyond a certain geographical line, an arbitrary settlement which severely affected the interests of the Bangali colonisers. Protected by this restrictive law the locals had launched a movement to oust the Bangali settlers across the so-called line. [Bongal Kheda - drive away the Banglees from Assam] On the 'line' issue, hostile relations developed between the Maulana and the Assam Chief Minister, Sir Muhammad Sa'dullah. At partition, Maulana Bhasani was in Goalpara district (Assam) organising the farmers against the line system. He was arrested by the government of Assam, and released towards the end of 1947 on condition that he would leave Assam for good.
Early in 1948 Maulana Bhasani came to East Bengal only to find himself brushed aside from the provincial leadership set-up. Disheartened, Bhasani contested and won a seat in the provincial assembly from south Tangail in a by-election defeating Khurram Khan Panni, the Muslim League candidate and Zamindar of Karatia. But the provincial governor nullified the results on grounds of foul play in the elections, and disqualified all the candidates from taking part in any election until 1950. Strangely enough, the ban on Panni was lifted in 1949 even though it remained in force on Bhasani.
In 1949 he went to Assam again, and was arrested and sent to Dhubri prison. On his release he came back to Dhaka. At about this time, the East Pakistan Muslim League was passing through a leadership crisis. The discontented elements of the Muslim League called a workers' convention in Dhaka on June 23 and 24 of 1949. Nearly 300 delegates from different parts of the province attended the convention. On June 24 a new political party, the East Pakistan Awami Muslim League, was launched with Maulana Bhasani as president and Shamsul Huq of Tangail as general secretary. ....." [Banglapedia]
Your assertion:
| "Maolana Bhasani asked the WB dewelers to Join BD for United Bengal as an independent conutry" |
is wrong.
By the way, Maolana Bashani was one of the first person to say "Assalamu Alaikum" to Pakistan.
[In 1957, Bhasani said 'good bye' (Assalamu Alaikum) to Pakistan ....]
Please think twice and read the history, before calling someone "Gondo Murkho or Dalal of India"......
Learn to "Agree to disagree" instead of false insuation & slanderous remarks...[as brother Faruque
item # 2 ].
Thank you;
Syed Aslam
--- On Tue, 5/20/08, Md. Mostafa Kamal @...> wrote:
RE: [notun_bangladesh] Now they want to accuse us as Communal
| Maolana Bhasani asked the WB dewelers to Join BD for United Bengal as an independent country. The High Race Hindus the Brahmman was against independent united Bengal. But K. Raisuddin wants united Bengal...... .is it BD to join with India or WB sever from India? How funny. We're happy with our 56000 sq. miles BD as an independent & sovereign country. We want a Prime Minister of BD like Khaleda Zia & not the Chief Minister like Sheikh Hasina. K. Raisuddin & his BAList gong have failed to show where I have written which is in favor of Pakistan same time that is against Bangladesh. CHORER MON, POLICE POLICE. Thank You All, Md. Mostafa Kamal. |
--- On Tue, 5/20/08, Kajimel Raisuddin <Kraisuddin@. ..> wrote:
From: Kajimel Raisuddin <Kraisuddin@. ..>
Subject: RE: [notun_bangladesh] Now they want to accuse us as Communal
To: notun_bangladesh@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 12:48 AM
BIRDS OF SAME FEATHER FLOCK TOGETHER. The Bangla Peoverb says, "Shngo gune shong". So, what other options open other than being Gondo Murkho. DALALS OF PAKI AND ARBIS THINK EVERYONE ELSE IS DALALTOO. Obak !!! that group is quite big, seeing all over.
To: notun_bangladesh@ yahoogroups. com
CC: Kraisuddin@hotmail. com; s_ayubi786@yahoo. com
From: mmk3k@yahoo. com
Date: Mon, 19 May 2008 12:10:58 -0700
Subject: RE: [notun_bangladesh] Now they want to accuse us as Communal
| I thought K. Raisuddina is an intelectual person. But he is not disimilar from Eng. Shafiq & his gong. K. Raisuddin has failed to reply Mr. Salahuddin Ayubi's point but diverting this debate attacking personally Mr. S. Ayubi by telling pondit etc bad words. It seems K .Raisuddin is either Gondo Murkho or Dalal of India.
Thank You All,
Md. Mostafa Kamal.
--- On Sun, 5/18/08, Kajimel Raisuddin <Kraisuddin@hotmail. com> wrote:
From: Kajimel Raisuddin <Kraisuddin@hotmail. com>
Subject: RE: [notun_bangladesh] Now they want to accuse us as Communal
To: notun_bangladesh@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Sunday, May 18, 2008, 12:01 AM
"You do not understand the history of this country". When you said so, Ayubi Pondit Shaheb, you closed the issue. Just tell me why did you write then the rest of the things in your passage? For bishho pondity, needs the audience, who want to see the substance and rationanle. I do see your postings here and there everywhere - and you do always vor vor, may you know or not. It has clearly been noticed that always you attempt to spread hate and vulgarity, short of any expressions of compassion, love or feelings. That's what the world poets do. Definitely not someone like you. You are of your a kind. Why don't you stay within your periphery! If you want to do bishho pondity, you should be able to understand the others and to learn how to talk with the others. Then you will understand where the folks such as a poor guy like me come from. Until then, its up to you, to decide on your role. Most of your postings are really disgusted, but I would never tell you anything any time. But this time you have hurt me personally, so badly in the public arena, that I had no other option, then to tell you couple of words. Extremely sorry about it.
To: notun_bangladesh@ yahoogroups. com
From: s_ayubi786@yahoo. com
Date: Fri, 16 May 2008 22:01:10 -0700
Subject: RE: [notun_bangladesh] Now they want to accuse us as Communal
| Mr. Raisuddin,
You do not understand the history of this country. Can you explain as to why the caste hindus opposed the partition of bengal tooth and nail in 1905 which prompted tagore to write our national anthem but in 1947 they meekly accepted the partition of bengal, they did not even consider the option of an independent Bengal that suhrwardy and sarat Bose tried to establish. The caste hindus has always been slefish and they have oppressed the backward Muslims of Bengal. Those sad stories probably you do not know or no one possilbly told you... I do not agree with you that the bengalis are one nation and they will ever unite. viva la difference!! !!!
Salahuddin Ayubi
--- On Fri, 5/16/08, Kajimel Raisuddin <Kraisuddin@hotmail. com> wrote:
From: Kajimel Raisuddin <Kraisuddin@hotmail. com>
Subject: RE: [notun_bangladesh] Now they want to accuse us as Communal
To: notun_bangladesh@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Friday, May 16, 2008, 10:04 PM
Anyone with the commitment as shown in the red below can not deviate from the principle of greatest lover of our mother and father land and also our birthplace. Anyone who does not possess these vested qualities may have different opinions. Certainly we value Bangla as the most sacred language since the genes of us and all our previous ancestors have been created out of Bangla. So, anyone who championed in Bangla is unquestionably always a champion to us. Please do not do something that becomes detrimental to this principle. So, Tagore and Nazrul can not be marked as just West Bengalis. They are Bangalis and our most champions in the Bangali nation. Bangalis are one nation. Physical reasons may have kept them separate. But the obvious situations will put them together some day in future. There was a politically incorrect staunch in the following write up.. I REALLY DO NOT APPRECIATE IT.
However, I understand where the angle settles finally. We may keep talking on these issues as long as we are honest and have no hidden agenda.
History: Robindranath did most of his works in kutibari that belongs to Bangladesh. He spent most of his life there, even though his zamindari was in Jurashku, West Bengal.. All his works on the nature are based on what Bangladesh looks like. West Bengal does not look like similar to what he felt and expressed in his poems and other works.. If it was today, he would be Bangladeshi. Nazrul was born in West Bengal but was raised in Trishal, Mymensingh by a Police Officer. He married in Comilla. Finally settled in Dhaka and died in Bangladesh ans also buried here.. So, please stop assigning them as a foreigner to Bangladesh. On the contrary, after partition of India and Pakistan, we were very generous to accept a huge number non-bengalis to our country. What they did finally? They never had allegiance to our land, to our language, and to our creed and culture. They were always opportunist. And at the end backed up the killer Pakistanis and they did the most killing. They did not stop there. Some of them learned Bangla or married Bangalee, posed to be converted as Bangalee but working in the underground with ISI, Saudis, and other agents and poisoning the society in Bangladesh. Some of them with old root even working for RAW. So, there are reasons why we must be careful such that these flock of mice can not cut everything of our home day in and day out.
| |
