General Moeen's Mysterious Harvard Seminar with Joy
http://shadakalo.blogspot.com/
[ Ed. note: Our guest blogger today has impressive foreign policy and economic credentials, but we are respecting his request for anonymity. While we were working on publishing this, Amader Shomoy is reporting that Gen. Moeen would be speaking to a seminar at the Ash Institute, and then meet Joy and 3 other students for lunch. We reported on the lunch yesterday, but we still can not verify the seminar story. Another imaginary Harvard moment? Let's go to our guest blogger's take on MUA's visit.
(views expressed in this article are not necessarily those of the ShadaKalo blog) ]
When Bangladeshi news media reported that the Bangladesh's 1st four star general Gen. Moeen U. Ahmed would deliver a seminar at the prestigious Harvard University's John F. Kennedy School of Government (KSG), we the Bangladeshi diaspora were delighted. We heard that the Harvard University invited our 'strongman' to deliver a historic speech 'on crisis management of democracy' that would be a model for nations to adopt. We echoed with the General's emotions that it would bring prestige to Bangladesh military and would build up our much needed image abroad. It would be historic event as the Harvard's 1st women President Gilpin Drew Faust in her inaugural speech on October 12, 2007 launched many special initiatives for Asia and we were pleased that our General would lead the President's Asian initiatives.
We were proud and happy at the news and therefore, we called the President's Office to thank her. Unfortunately her office appeared to have no knowledge of our General's scheduled talk. Being frustrated, we contacted other offices of the KSG basically to get an invitation to listen to his historic speech. But to our dismay, we were told that the 'Bangladeshi general has no public forum or talk at the university'. We were further told that he might have been privately invited by a lecturer of the university for his class. The university administration has no knowledge of it.
Rumors spread quickly. Bangladeshi Diaspora of Boston reported that Professor S. Bose of the Harvard University belonging to West Bengal had requested another well liked Bengali educationist, Dr. Gowher Rizvi, Director of the Harvard's Ash Institute for Democratic Governance and Innovation to sponsor a public forum for the Bangladeshi General. Few months ago, he arranged a seminar for Professor Rehman Sobhan of Bangladesh. However, when we searched the Ash Institute's program events, we did not find any public seminar with General Moeen Ahmed. Instead we find that there was a seminar on 'Muslims in America' on October 17th. Our frustration prompted us to call the Institute. They politely stated that no Bangladeshi general is their guest speaker at this time. We also inquired at the KSG but of no avail. The mystery intensified.
We were simply stunned at it. Our hopes and expectations got a jolt. How a set program could be so illusive? Following our national leaders especially our Law Advisor Mainul Hosein, we immediately thought that there must be a 'conspiracy' to undermine Bangladesh and Islam. The RAW of India may be behind it!! Others quipped that the Bangladesh Embassy officials belonging to BNP-AL might have foiled his scheduled talk at the KSG. To justify our hunch we concocted arguments. When General Moeen arrived in Boston he was neither been accompanied by the Bangladesh Ambassador, nor the PR, nor the Consul General. Secondly, we thought since former Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina's son Sajeeb Wazed Joy is a student at the Kennedy School, he might have foiled it. However, his classmates reported that they were very busy with Mid-term exams. Thirdly, the AL and the BNP supporters might have arranged a massive protest owing to which Harvard University cancelled the seminar. But fact of the matter is, there was no protest, no demonstrations. Interestingly, the local AL Vice President Abul Kalam Azad received Gen. Moeen at the airport. More importantly, we learned that in the 300 plus years history of the Harvard University they never ever withdraw any invitation once it was issued even against all odds and protests. Does it mean that the General's much celebrated trip was a 'hawk' or a total lie?
We don't know who tried to foil our General's program or malign our General. Recently, three stories became public about Gen. Moeen. First one pertaining to his receiving loans of Tk99 lakh from the Trust Bank that is recorded in the Bank's prospectus submitted to the government, the Bangladesh Bank and the Security & Exchange Commission. Second, the re-appointment of his elder brother at the Trust Bank of which he is the ex-officio Chairperson and Director thus violating the government regulation that no two family members could be appointed as Directors of the same bank. Third, his brother-in-law grabbed properties of few people in Maulvibazar by misusing his power. Are these true or manipulated? It is charged that Bangladesh officials that we trust often do manipulate things to meet the wishes of their boss, the rich and the powerful.
As per reports, he was invited by a Harvard lecturer who is rumored to be appointed as a Consultant in Bangladesh. The said lecturer is an authority on election reform and US congressional issues. He also takes classes of 'freshman lawmakers'. It is reported that our General would attend one of his classes along with his students. Each teacher in American universities or colleges routinely invites guest speakers in his/her classes and Gen. Moeen might have gotten such an invitation. Who knows?
We also checked the KSG bulletin boards. The 2 days that our general would be around Harvard, the KSG will be hosting nearly 7 public seminars and none on issues relating to South Asia or Bangladesh. They had an event on Bangladesh on October 13, the Eid day--a public lecture of Nobel Laureate Dr. Muhammad Yunus.
Apparently General Moeen did not arrange any meeting with any leader of Massachusetts or of the U. S. Other than Congressman Crowley of New York, he has no appointments either with any U. S. Senators or US Congressmen/women, or with senior State Department officials. Nor there is any especial meeting with the Pentagon or with senior US Army officers as per media reports. He is visiting the U. S. at a time when nine U.S. lawmakers have placed a bill to allow tax-free imports from developing countries including Bangladesh and his courtesy meetings with the US lawmakers could help passing of such bill. However, he refrained from such lobbying. Then question is; why he made such a long trip to US when his each minute is so precious and crucial?
He had a 'secret public appearance' for nearly 50 minutes at a location in Holbrook a tiny town, away from Boston on October 21. The guests were instructed to maintain utmost secrecy of the event. The reason for such secrecy is reportedly due to their fear that if Bangladeshi Diaspora knows about the event, they would stage protest demonstrations as they did in Florida.
It was a private dinner party arranged by one Mr. Shaheen Khan, a convenience store owner and more importantly, Mr. Khan is a friend of the general's brother who lives in Florida. Reportedly this was arranged to thank the General as Mr. Khan's uncle, Nurul Islam, a sacked Secretary to Begum Khaleda Zia has been reinstated. Other than family members, nearly 25/30 local people were invited at the dinner and everybody had to finish their eating before Gen. Moeen entered the venue at 9:15 PM. Private security was arranged by Mr. Khan. However, TV cameramen and selected journalists were invited at the event.
It is ironic that General Moeen, the man who started jihad against corruption and corrupt people was welcomed at the dinner party by none other than a businessman who made his fortune through bankruptcy and defrauding creditors. He was a real estate developer in the 1980s and he collected millions of dollars from thousands of people including many Bangladeshis with the promise to double/triple their investments. Unfortunately, once funds were collected, he declared 'bankruptcy' and his Ivy Inc. was closed down. Local TV and print media covered it widely when even his lawyer was jailed for fraud. For nearly 12 years, he stayed away from public eyes. However, in recent days, he emerged and is currently a leader of the Bangladesh Islamic Society of New England. General Moeen might not know that the man who welcomed him and solicited his help for investment in Bangladesh once defrauded his customers, his bank, and his well wishers.
It is rumored that General's mission to the US is to meet Sheikh Hasina's family members. He visited Florida where his only son, his brother and also Hasina's daughter live. At Harvard, it is rumored that he wanted to meet Sajeeb Wajed Joy. It is rumored that instead of a private meeting Joy suggested an open meeting. The General, therefore, have reportedly invited all the 4 Bangladeshi students of the KSG to have luncheon with him on October 23, the day of his departure to China. It is believed that after this meeting, he would decide as to how to deal with Sheikh Hasina, the leader of the AL party now under detention. It may be mentioned that as per media reports, Joy met Indian Foreign Minister during his trip to New York few weeks ago and that might prompted General Moeen to have a face-to-face dialogue with Joy.
Gen. Moeen while answering a question at the Holbrook private dinner jokingly stated that there could be many changes in the next 14 months….a king can die, even a hoarse can fly (something impossible). Now who knows what's next.
[* Moderator's Note - CHOTTALA is a non-profit, non-religious, non-political and non-discriminatory organization.
* Disclaimer: Any posting to the CHOTTALA are the opinion of the author. Authors of the messages to the CHOTTALA are responsible for the accuracy of their information and the conformance of their material with applicable copyright and other laws. Many people will read your post, and it will be archived for a very long time. The act of posting to the CHOTTALA indicates the subscriber's agreement to accept the adjudications of the moderator]
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe
__,_._,___
2 comments:
An interesting insight into several things, J. Anyway, my congratulations on the information you shared with us. I do think you're giving General Moeen too much credit for his non-answers, I don't think it's too challenging for anyone with average intelligence to claim that something is beyond his jurisdiction. On the other hand, the way that Moeen has acted recently, it was probably quite a challenge for his ego, which does not seem at all to be average-size.
Do you anticipate any more follow-up news from Boston?
Tacit:
The other blog has been updated, and the author's name has been redacted. So I had to blow away your comment, too--I hope you understand.
For what I heard, MUA was gracious and charming today.
Personally, I don't mind big egos, and I am not morally opposed to a honest, retired general entering politics. With 'honest' and 'retired' being the two key words. I'd say we will see 'retired' in play soon.
I don't anticipate any followups soon, but who knows what tomorrow will bring. A public meeting is the best cover for a private meeting between Joy and MUA. Did one happen? People I know who know Joy will ask him detailed questions, and it is unlikely that he will answer them beyond what is already known.
Only time will tell.